Famous engine and gearbox problems to know before you buy
The best-known failures of popular engines and gearboxes, from BMW's M57 swirl flaps to the Subaru EJ25 head gasket and dual-clutch gearbox faults, with what to ask and check.
By the WYG team · 12 min read · Last reviewed 10 November 2026
How to use this list
Most engines and gearboxes are fine. A few have well-documented weak points that show up across many cars at similar ages and mileages, and those are worth knowing about before you buy, because the fix can cost thousands. This list covers some of the best-known patterns. Not every car with these units is affected, a problem may only apply to certain years or versions, and a fix that has already been done is good news. Treat each entry as a question to ask the seller, then confirm the details for the exact car with an inspection by someone who knows the model.
Repair costs vary widely by country and by who does the work, so this guide describes what fails and why it matters, rather than quoting prices.
BMW M57 3.0-litre diesel (about 2002 to 2010)
A strong, torquey diesel that many owners love, but with a famous weakness: the intake manifold has swirl flaps, small butterfly valves that are held on by small fixings. Over time the flaps and their actuators can wear and in the worst case a flap can break away and be drawn into a cylinder, which can destroy the engine. Many owners fit blanking plates or have the flaps removed, and a car that has had this done properly is a better buy than one that has not. Ask whether the flaps have been dealt with, and by whom. The related M47 2.0-litre diesel from the mid-2000s has similar flaps.
BMW N47 2.0-litre diesel (about 2007 to 2014)
The timing chain sits at the back of the engine next to the gearbox, where it is hard to reach, and on some engines the chain guides wear and the chain can fail, which causes severe engine damage. Repair usually means removing the engine or the gearbox. Signs include a rattle from the back of the engine, particularly on a cold start. Ask for evidence the chain has been replaced or inspected, and for the history of any warning lights.
BMW N54 3.0-litre twin-turbo petrol (about 2007 to 2016)
An enthusiast favourite with plenty of tuning potential, but the early cars are known for high-pressure fuel pump failures, leaking injectors and rattling wastegate actuators. The symptoms are rough running, hesitation and warning lights, and several parts may need replacing over the car's life. A well-maintained car with these items already done can be good value, and a tuned car deserves extra scrutiny.
BMW N20 2.0-litre turbo petrol (about 2011 to 2016)
Plastic timing chain guides can wear, which lets the chain slacken and in the worst case jump, damaging the engine. Early signs are a rattle on a cold start or an engine warning light. Cars that have had the chain and guides replaced with updated parts are a safer purchase.
BMW S54 and S65 high-performance engines (E46 M3 and E9x M3)
These screaming, high-revving engines are known for rod bearing wear. When a bearing fails it can wreck the engine, so many owners replace the bearings as preventive maintenance and have the oil analysed. A documented bearing replacement is a major plus. Without one, price in the possibility of a costly job.
BMW S55 3.0-litre twin-turbo petrol (F80 M3, F82 M4, F87 M2 Competition, about 2014 to 2020)
A great engine with one famous flaw that many buyers, and plenty of enthusiasts, have never heard of: the crank hub. This is the part that drives the timing and the oil pump from the end of the crankshaft, and on many cars it can slowly spin loose on the shaft. Once it slips, the timing drifts out and the engine can be destroyed. The cure is a pinned or upgraded crank hub, so ask for the invoice and the date, and treat a car without one as needing the job done.
Separately, the S55's rod bearings are a known wear point on hard-driven cars, so an oil analysis and any bearing replacement history are worth asking for. Plastic charge pipes also crack and are cheap to replace with aluminium ones. With the crank hub fixed and the bearings checked, the S55 is a strong, durable engine.
Volkswagen and Audi EA888 2.0 turbo petrol, early generations
The first two generations of this widely used engine (from about 2008 to 2014) are known for timing chain tensioner problems, which can allow the chain to skip, and for high oil consumption from worn piston rings. Check the oil level and ask how often the owner has topped it up. Later generations changed the design. When shopping, find out which generation the car has, since the model name alone does not say.
Volkswagen group 2.0 TDI common-rail diesels
Some common-rail versions used a high-pressure fuel pump that has a reputation for failing, in the worst case sending metal particles through the fuel system, which means replacing much of it. Look for evidence of service work on the fuel system and avoid cars with a history of fuel-related warning lights.
Dry-clutch DSG (DQ200) seven-speed gearboxes
Volkswagen group dual-clutch gearboxes of this type are known for faults in the mechatronic control unit and for clutch wear, causing jerky low-speed behaviour, hesitation and warning messages. They can be expensive to repair. During a test drive, pay close attention to how the car creeps in traffic and takes off from a standstill, and ask for service records. The wet-clutch six-speed DSG is generally regarded as more durable, provided its fluid and filter service has been done on time.
Mercedes-Benz M271, M272 and M273 petrol engines
The four-cylinder M271 is known for timing chain stretch, and the V6 and V8 M272 and M273 engines from the mid-2000s are known for balance shaft gear wear, which can lead to engine failure. Cars from the affected years benefit from documented repairs. Ask which engine code the car has and which years are involved.
Mercedes-Benz 7G-Tronic (722.9) automatic
A generally good gearbox, but the electronic conductor plate inside can fail, causing erratic shifts or limp mode. It is a known repair rather than a total gearbox failure, and many cars have it done once. Check whether it has been addressed.
Subaru EJ25 non-turbo (about 1999 to 2011)
A very well-known weakness: head gasket leaks. Signs are coolant loss, overheating, white smoke and a sweet smell, and the repair is a major job. A car that has had a quality head gasket repair with upgraded parts is a better buy than one that has not. The turbocharged EJ257 used in the WRX STI has its own risk: ringland damage when the engine is tuned badly or detonates, so a tuned STI deserves a careful inspection.
Toyota 2AZ-FE 2.4-litre (about 2002 to 2009)
Used in popular Camry and RAV4 models, some of these engines burn oil and some suffer head bolt thread failure that leads to head gasket leaks. Check the oil level and ask how much the owner adds between changes. Regular oil changes help, and an engine with no consumption problem is a good one.
Nissan Jatco CVT gearboxes
Nissan's continuously variable transmissions from certain years have a reputation for overheating, juddering and early failure, and they cost a lot to replace. They can be fine if the fluid has been changed on schedule. Ask for the fluid service history, and on the test drive look for shuddering, a whine or hesitation. Not all CVTs are the same: some other makers' units have a better record.
Ford PowerShift (DPS6) dual-clutch gearbox
Fitted to some Focus, Fiesta and EcoSport models from about 2011 to 2016, this dry-clutch gearbox is known for shuddering, clutch wear and control-module failures. Repairs can be costly and sometimes repeated. Drive the car carefully in stop-start traffic before buying, and check whether any updates or warranty work were done.
Ford 5.4-litre three-valve V8
Known for spark plugs that can blow out of the cylinder head on some engines, and for cam phaser wear that causes a rattle on start-up. Both repairs can be expensive. Ask whether the plugs and phasers have been dealt with.
General Motors V8 engines with active fuel management
Cylinder deactivation systems on some 5.3 and 6.2-litre engines (roughly 2007 onward) are associated with lifter failure, which causes misfires and can damage the camshaft. Some owners fit disabling devices. Check for a ticking noise and a history of misfire codes.
Porsche M96 and M97 flat-six engines (Boxster and 911, about 1997 to 2008)
Famous for the intermediate shaft bearing, which can fail and destroy the engine. Preventive retrofits exist and many cars have had them. A car with a documented retrofit is much more reassuring, and a car without one needs a lower price and a careful specialist inspection.
Mazda rotary engines (RX-7 and RX-8)
Rotary engines have apex seals that wear and lead to loss of compression, and they are sensitive to hot starts and oil use. Compression testing by a rotary specialist is essential before buying. A rebuilt engine from a reputable specialist is a major positive.
Hyundai and Kia Theta II 2.0 and 2.4 GDI engines
Some engines from roughly 2011 to 2019 suffered connecting rod bearing failure, which led to recalls and extended warranties in some markets. Ask whether the car was part of a recall, whether the engine software update was done and whether it has had a replacement engine. Keep the service records, because warranty coverage often depends on them.
Mini and Peugeot-Citroen THP turbo engines (Prince family)
The 1.6-litre turbo petrol made with BMW and PSA suffers from timing chain stretch, carbon build-up on the intake valves and high oil consumption in some cars. Check the oil, listen for a chain rattle and ask what the owner has paid to fix. The later 1.2-litre PureTech engines use a rubber belt that runs in the oil and can break down, so check that the belt has been changed on time.
How to protect yourself
- Identify the exact engine and gearbox before you buy. One model often comes with several, and only some have the known problem.
- Look up the model's known issues in owner forums, recalls and technical service bulletins for your country.
- Ask for the work history on the specific weak point.
- Pay for an independent inspection by a specialist who knows the unit.
- Price the risk in. A car with a known weak point already fixed is worth more than one without, and a car with the fix still due should be priced lower by the cost of the job.
How Dyno uses this information
Dyno keeps a list of the best-known failures for many engines and gearboxes and makes sure they appear in a car's report, with a typical repair cost, even when a listing does not mention them. It is a guide to what to ask and check, not a diagnosis of any individual car.
Check a car with Dyno
Paste a listing link and get a value range, reliability, known weak points and red flags in seconds. It handles cars and bikes. Three checks are free.
More guides
General information only, not legal, financial or mechanical advice. Prices, rules and what is known about a particular engine or gearbox differ by country, year and version and change over time, so confirm the details for the specific car or bike with an independent inspection and your local authority.
